Skip to main content

Ruthless - First Thoughts - Iain McAllister

This Review is based of a first playthrough of the game at UK Games Expo. I do not own it, though have pre-ordered, and have not read the rulebook.

Arr matey that be a fine deckbuilder that you have there. Be a real shame if some plucky young game set sails on the choppy seas of game releases and blew a hole in your bloated side, making off with all the best loot and leaving you with naught but an accordion playing parrot and a memory of how good you used to have it. Ruthless folk would do that to you and those scurvy dogs from Alley Cat Games might be the crew to carry it off. Now get up in that crow's nest and see if we can't tell which way the wind is blowing.

Cards are final, components are not and it will not come with metal coins. But it’s already a damn fine looking game

Batten Down the Hatches!!

Deckbuilding has become a rather overused mechanic in the last few years, being forced into every genre under the sun. I’ll admit that it does lend a sense of replayability to a lot of games but I often feel it is turning up because it is such an easy go to mechanic, with a ready made army of loyal fans. For myself and my regular crew it often falls into the category of lonely fun, with individual players barely interacting over the course of play. Not so in Ruthless.

This was one of my only appointments during the con and I was really glad I made it. The whole thing took an hour tops and we were lucky enough to be taught by game designer and artist Roland MacDonald. What immediately caught my eye about Ruthless was that I had a thinning mechanic built into my starter deck. You have cards called Powder Monkeys which can be used in two ways, one of which is to permanently remove cards. I honestly can't recall the other. I really liked that you could start deck thinning right from the off, giving you a choice to make without even having added a single new card to your deck.

My next surprise came when we bought our first card from the central river. Not only will these cards make their way into your hand, but when you buy them they join your crew, more on that shortly, and you can use their ability. This was very often a choice between two different actions, giving you significant decisions with every buy. It also meant the game felt very dynamic: there were things happening all the time that demanded a response. Many of the abilities even allowed you to attack the other players or mess with the river, spoiling their plans.

Ross from @moregamesplease probably planning to mess with me

To add a wrinkle into the buying of crew, there’s a poker-based set collection mechanic. The aim of the game is to get victory points and the primary way you can do that is making sure you have the best scurvy dogs aboard your fine vessel. Only the best crew will be able to help you raid the biggest ships and as you buy from the central reserve and play crew out of your hand you will build up poker style combinations on the table: straights, three of a kind etc. These combinations contribute to the overall strength of your crew and the person with the strongest bunch of miscreants gets to raid the most valuable ships. This provides another really interesting point of choice: do you go for a powerful action with immediate benefits, or is it better to take a weaker card that will give you better poker combos this round, knowing they may not be as useful later on.

Of course no game about pirates would be complete without some plunder, and Ruthless is no exception. When you dive into the treasure deck you, once again, get a card that gives you an interesting choice: money now, or a card in your deck that will give you money over and over. On top of this we had an end game condition that gave victory points to the person with the most plunder cards in their deck, adding an extra wrinkle to the decision.

The parrot can be any other value in that suit, so yeah that is 3 burly pirate men and definitely not two pirates and a parrot. No siree.
It's a Pirates Life for Me..

Ruthless really feels like the deck builder refined: pacey, short playing, lots of decisions to make every turn, and a dynamic use of cards. It’s a gorgeous looking game, with evocative art, excellent graphic design, and a strong reflection of its theme throughout. Its short playtime encourages you to experiment with different strategies. By the end of my game I could see different paths and I immediately wanted to play again. A good game should do this: Be just long enough and good enough to leave you wanting to crack out another game straight away, not outstay its welcome past the point of .maximum fun.

Now, pass me that parrot, I've got some pirating to do.

 If you enjoyed this article then please check out my other work on The Giant Brain were you can find reviews, critique and con reports alongside The Brainwaves Podcast. A share and a like really helps but if you would like to go further you can support The Giant Brain on Patreon. 


Popular posts from this blog

Darwin's Choice - Treeceratops Games - Preview

Darwin’s Choice - Treeceratops Games - Kickstarter Preview

Let’s start this preview by putting things in perspective. There’s a reasonably large amount of pressure placed on a preview for a Kickstarter game that isn’t live yet, that isn’t in other people’s hands and isn’t already out there with a general consensus on whether it is generally enjoyable or wash out. It’s a lot to take in that maybe your thoughts are the thing that could maybe sway someone’s opinion to back or not bother. That you could effectively hold the lifeline or axe over someone who has potentially spent years developing their product.
At the same time, I owe it to you to make you sure that you read this knowing that I completely adore you, and would hate the thought of you potentially wasting a few hours of your precious time, playing a game that at the end you put in that cupboard.  You know, the one where you store the games that aren’t easy to access, the ones that eventually end up at the charity shop, because …

Hey Kickstarter, let's make some noise

It's been an interesting year for the crowdfunding platform, with its share of multi-million dollar successes, controversies surrounding outright potential fraud and plagiarism, and continuing dramas centering around project fulfillment or lack there of. We have our first taste of Kickstarter as an actual pre-order store and our stalwart Big Name behemoths seeing push backs against some of their expected successes.
At the centre of it all, the old debates surface and swirl and disappear only to surface again. For those jumping on the platform for their first time, with their game clutched tightly to their chest, they'll often hear the echoes of previous creators ringing in their ears.
'Kickstarter isn't fair'
'Kickstarter has raised the bar for everyone'
'Kickstarter makes it impossible for those without a budget'
'Kickstarter isn't for those who aren't prepared to make an effort'
'Kickstarter won't help those who don't do …

Gloom of Kilforth - A Fantasy Quest Game

Gloom of Kilforth

An innovative take on the fantasy adventure genre, the game boasts incredible artwork and a superb theme. You are an adventurer looking to tell their tale in the form of a three part saga. Each part of the saga is completed by collecting keywords from locations and encounters.

As a first offering from designer Tristan Hall, this was a very ambitious project and 10 years on the making. His decision to use only one artist to produce the unique pieces of art for over 300 cards led to quite a big delay, but the result is a truly stunning looking game with a consistent feel. Every time you draw a card, you will spend a moment just taking in it's beauty. This coherence really helps in immersing the players into a fantasy world akin to a Tolkien story.

You choose from a selection of heroes races and classes, the variety of which will give many combinations, keeping the game fresh. Then, choose a 'saga' - a personal quest spanning 4 chapters that you must complet…